Jump to content

Which 56mm?

kielinski

By kielinski
in Fuji X Lenses

 Share

Recommended Posts

kielinski Explorer

kielinski

Posted
Posted

I stopped in to my local camera shop to actually handle these lenses.  Both felt great and were of sturdy construction.  After reading online reviews I'm finding it difficult to justify buying the APD over the regular lens.

 

APD Pros:

Smoother bokeh

Maybe slightly more contrast

 

APD Cons:

About 1 stop less light transmission (could be a problem in low light conditions)

Considerably more expensive

 

Anyone have any thoughts/opinions?

Link to post
Share on other sites
mjh Enthusiast

mjh

Posted
Posted

An argument in favour of the non-APD version would be its support for phase-detection AF. It all boils down to the question whether an extremely pleasant bokeh is of paramount importance to you. If it is then by all means go for the APD. Otherwise the normal, non-APD version is the more versatile choice.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Maurice Community Regular

Maurice

Posted
Posted

Indeed, i have read that too about the phase detect AF. Another Con.

 

That's a lot of Cons for one special effect, you will have something unique that's for sure, but on the other hand some people say it almost looks too artificial -like photoshop blur. :(

 

Also, there are many ways available to DIY by modifying a standard UV filter for example:

 

But .. i do get the appeal of wanting to have that special version of a already fantastic lens. :rolleyes:

Maintaining maximum performance that a DIY hack of course will not.

Link to post
Share on other sites
mjh Enthusiast

mjh

Posted
Posted

Also, there are many ways available to DIY by modifying a standard UV filter for example.

Yeah, but achieving the APD effect – excellent sharpness within the depth of field, combined with a really smooth bokeh both behind and in front of this zone – by any other means is next to impossible.

 

An undercorrected lens (the standard choice for a smooth background bokeh) would also compromise sharpness within the depth of field and the foreground bokeh suffers as well.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 4 months later...
gamblor Newbie

gamblor

Posted
Posted

I couldn't find an official 56mm thread so I'll post here.

On Monday I won an auction for the 56mm but unfortunately it wasn't as nice as described and I sent it back. I did get to test it out though. Absolutely beautiful image quality!

My question is, how is the focus ring on everyone's 56? The one I had had a really slippery focus ring and I couldn't even put the lens on the camera without spinning the focus ring and aperture ring inadvertently a few times.

 

Now, I'm just wondering if paying more for a brand new 56mm is worth it, rather than trying to save $100 on a used one.

Link to post
Share on other sites
PatrickB Apprentice

PatrickB

Posted
Posted

I'd get the regular 56mm, which is around €300,00 cheaper at the moment, and spend the difference in a 90mm f2. This would give more compression, smoother bokeh and transitions than a 56mm. 

 

Gamblor, the ring is awkward indeed, I usually grab the end of the lens or the lens hood. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
gamblor Newbie

gamblor

Posted
Posted

Ah ok (re: the ring). Does yours turn super easily then? I'm just wondering if that was just the used one I got. On Fuji vs Fuji he says it's tight.

 

As for which one to get, I'm definitely getting the regular 56mm. I was just wondering whether to pay 90,000 yen for a brand new one or keep looking for a used one in good condition for 75000 to 80,000yen.

 

I'm definitely not interested in the 90mm as 1)my studio is too small and 2) I'd rather get the 50-140

Link to post
Share on other sites
Dis Collaborator

Dis

Posted
Posted

Ah ok (re: the ring). Does yours turn super easily then? I'm just wondering if that was just the used one I got. On Fuji vs Fuji he says it's tight.

Focus ring is quite tight. Nevertheless it doesn't help mounting the lens. One has to grab it by aperture ring in the end position or by the lens front and rear at the same time by one hand. It's not easy but you'll get used to it.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Tom H. Experienced

Tom H.

Posted
Posted

I have the APD. I never used the normal one. The aperture ring is far too loose for my taste, but that is subjective. Some like it that way. Focus ring is nice and smooth. Focus is improved with latest firmware V4 on the X-T1, even if it's not using phase detect AF. Not a lens for fast action though, but I use it for street shooting from time to time and don't have any real issues. It renders in a very pleasing tone, remembers me of my old Canon 135 f2. But better and sharper and without and aberrations.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Similar Content

  • Posts

    • jerryy
      GFX 100s not connecting to Mac via USB-C

      By jerryy · Posted

      Hopefully these will help some. For quite a while now Apple has put stuff into their operating system so that you cannot yourself open the connected camera’s card and see the images, you have to use their or third party software to do that.
    • jmm123
      GFX 100s not connecting to Mac via USB-C

      By jmm123 · Posted

      Thanks for the instructions:  I was doing up to 3 successfully but can't wait to get home and try  4 and 5 and report back. Cheers, John
    • jerryy
      GFX 100s not connecting to Mac via USB-C

      By jerryy · Posted

      Okay, just for completeness sake: 1.     The camera’s menu connection setting is USB CARD READER. 2.    The computer is turned on, booted and nicely operational. 3..    With the camera turned off, connect the camera to the computer using a known-to-be-good USB C data plus power cable (a data only cable should work as well, a power only cable will not work). 3.   The camera’s charging light may turn on. Turn the camera on. The back screen probably will show the USB symbol as well as the USB letters. 4.    Start up the Image Capture app and see if the camera’s name appears in the devices list. 5.    In the Apple menu, select ‘About This Mac’, click on the ‘More Info…’ button, and on the right hand side of the window that opens, at its bottom is a button called ‘System Report…’, click on it. A new window should open, the left hand side has collapsible dropdown listings, the first is called “Hardware’, within it is the USB listing, select that. The right side pane should give you listings of all the USB devices connected at that moment, one of them should say something like USB PTP Camera. Does either 4. or 5. work?
    • jmm123
      GFX 100s not connecting to Mac via USB-C

      By jmm123 · Posted

      Thanks, Yes I knew about the USB issue in newer Macs and macOS but that is why I tested it with High Sierra as well. Also the fact that every other camera easily connects via USB direct with the camera - definitely points out the fact that it is a FUJI specific problem.  Furthermore - I remember being able to direct connect early last year. I rarely take the Cards OUT of the camera  these days. The weird thing is I can connect my iPhone 15 via USB-C to 100s and pull files directly - puzzling. Problem is FUJI rarely listens to anyone.    
    • Jk1006
      Focus Sound on NEW XF33mm F1.4 R LM WR

      By Jk1006 · Posted

      Hi all, I notice that there are some focusing sound on my XF33 despite it being said as completely silent in many review. The focusing sound is kind of like stepping motor sound, and it only appears when I’m shooting photo. I try shooting near and far away and there is sound. However, it is completely silence when I shoot videos. Is it normal or do I need to change some of my setting? Or am I just getting a not too good copy haha. please assist me with the matter guys! Thanks!
×
×
  • Create New...