I was pointing out the coma as a negative aspect of the lens. I was comparing it to two the best 24mm equiv. lenses out there (that I know of). Show me an Auto Focusing 24mm f1.4 weather sealed lens that is smaller, less expensive and doesn't produce coma shot wide open. I did not even come close to saying it's better than any lens at any focal length for any purpose. This lens isn't marketed as an astro lens, OP didn't say anything about shooting astro, I just wanted to agree that the coma was terrible but point out that the other top lenses at this focal length suffer from the same problem. Don't you think the coma is terrible? Glad we agree. Is there a lens that has ever been made that corrects for coma, yes, lots. Is there a lens that makes better bokeh, so so many. But OP wasn't asking about those, he was asking about the XF16mm.
winnaford got a reaction from claude in Fuji 16mm F/1.4 - Can I get some user feedback?