Jump to content

16-55 vs 56


jclone

Recommended Posts

Hi,

When I started getting into the Fuji system, I got attracted very fast to the 56mm f/1.2 because it is such a luxurious piece of glass. I got it cheap-ish too.

It is a wonderful lens. But big and special. My wife and kid do not like to pose, so I am doing more spontaneous portraits. The AF of the 56mm really struggles there. I feel I get great shots when I catch them still.

I tend to take the 35mm f/1.4 more which always give great images (even for portraits). So I have this 800dollars brick sitting way too often on the shelve.

The other side of the story is that I barely use the 18-55mm kit. It's technically ok, but I somehow never impress by the shots it makes and I suspect I have a "bad" copy as I randomly get complete OOF shots, which makes me insecure when I use it.

 

So I thought, sell 18-55 and 56. Buy 16-55 and some tele legacy glass for portrait work.

 

I found a reasonable cheap 16-55. Have it since 2-3 days. God, it is monstrously big. The IQ is flawless. But what is more amazing is the AF. Very confident and sure.

Will play with the setup more, but I figure yes I' ll carry a big lens, but it'll be very versatile at least. Paired with a 16mm f/1.4 and 35mm f/1.4, I think it'd make a great general setup.

Things may change when that 50mm f/2 gets out.

 

Am I making sense? anybody went through some similar thoughts?

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm in a similar situation to you, but never actually parted with any money for the 56 as (for me, anyway) it's just too specialised. Like you I sold my 18-55 as I never got on with it (poor IQ and unreliable AF) and bought the 16-55. A great lens, but it's like walking around with a can of beans glued onto the front of the camera. If I only take one lens then this is the one; but, more usually, I tend to leave it at home and take primes (16/23/35) instead. I always try to make room in my camera bag for two other lenses, though: the 10-24 and 50-140. The latter is an absolutely stunner, and extremely versatile for candid shots. OK, so it costs more than 800 dollars, but I can assure you that it wouldn't end up sitting on the shelf like your 56!

 

Ian.

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Link to post
Share on other sites

Which x camera are you using?

 

I found the 56 slow until I paired it to the Pro2. I chased my kid down the go kart track with some success.

 

I think that the 16-55 is a wonderful piece of glass.....but way too big for a compact x system. I travel with the X camera so size and weight is important to me. Depending on where I go and what I intend to photograph, I usually carry 3 prime lenses with me. If space allow, I pack another body.

 

If you intend to stay with your existing x camera, then yes, perhaps the 16-55 is the way to go for you.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Which x camera are you using?

 

I found the 56 slow until I paired it to the Pro2. I chased my kid down the go kart track with some success.

 

I think that the 16-55 is a wonderful piece of glass.....but way too big for a compact x system. I travel with the X camera so size and weight is important to me. Depending on where I go and what I intend to photograph, I usually carry 3 prime lenses with me. If space allow, I pack another body.

 

If you intend to stay with your existing x camera, then yes, perhaps the 16-55 is the way to go for you.

I use an X-Pro 2 (was using X-E1 before). It's faster for sure, but we' re touching the limits of how fast can the lens elements move...

Link to post
Share on other sites

For me, having 16-55 makes 16f1.4 redundant. I'd get rid of it, buy 90f2 for portraits and won't messing with legacy glass at this stage.

For indoors in winter time, there's nothing that makes the 16mm 1.4 redundant. The draw to the Fuji system for me is those super fast primes. 

If anything I'd sell the 10-24mm (given that I also have the Samyang 12mm)

 

The 90mm f/2 is a good point though, I hear it's AF is up there and it's a macro lens as well is it?

Edited by jclone
Link to post
Share on other sites

I have both lenses, 56mm gets little use but every time I think about selling it, I end up using it and loving the output.

 

Specialised? yes but wonderful output!

 

Part of the joy of the X system vs a FF camera for me is that I can have a wide range of high quality glass vs a small selection of expensive L lenses. After all, if cameras and lenses are tools I'd rather have a few quality screwdrivers and a hammer for different situations, as opposed to one super duper hammer!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Posts

    • As far as I know the firmware is not country specific. Are you sure that the filename has not been changed ( I am told this can happen with mac os). That's the only thing I can think of.
    • My x-t5 does not exhibit the focusing switch behaviour as you report it, so that is very strange and indicative of a fault. It does not matter whether the flash is attached or not. Once you set the camera for your studio flash, say 1/250th at f5.6, the camera, which is showing you what you will get at that exposure without the flash, will show a black screen unless the ambient light is brighter than what you would typically get indoors. That is why, as Jerry says, you have to set preview exp/wb to off. I have set a button for this.
    • I connected to FRAME.IO a while back and it works fine, but the camera wouldn't connect to the internet all of a sudden today and would get stuck on the reset screen, including initializing and even switching USB Connection mode. Is anyone else experiencing the same thing?
    • I used this for the latest firmware no problems. https://fujifilm-x.com/en-gb/support/download/firmware/cameras/x-t2/
    • I was just about to point that out, in my defense. 
×
×
  • Create New...