Jump to content

Canon TS-E 17mm on X-T4


Recommended Posts

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Has anyone tried to adapt a Canon TS-E lens to any Fuji body? I'm specifically thinking about getting the 17mm for my X-T4, however I'm still weighing up the cost against the diminishing returns.

In general, how viable is adapting full-frame tilt-shift onto APS-C bodies? As far as I understand, on top of the focal length being increased by the crop factor, the shift range is also reduced by the same factor. So in the case of the 17mm, I would technically only have a maximum shift of 7-8mm. Is this correct? If so, is that still enough for a moderate amount of in-camera correction? I'm not expecting to capture a skyscraper from the across the street, but something that will cover the majority of cases.

Finally, are there any alternative solutions I should consider?

Link to post
Share on other sites

You get more shift range, not less, as shift is controlled by the difference between the illumination circle and the sensor size, and that ratio grows when using a shift lens intended for FF on APS-C.

That said, I'd honestly suggest pairing a shift adapter or T/S adapter and a FF UWA over going to a lens as insanely expensive as the 17 TS-E if you aren't going to get the benefit of the full wideness of the lens.

I've got the Laowa 15mm f4 Macro, which includes native shift in 1 axis, and it does pretty well. As it's a FF UWA with shift available only on APS-C, you are limited to ~7mm of shift, but it's $500 and can be used with a 3rd party shift adapter to get other shift directions (it's a DSLR lens in F, EF or K mount)

Link to post
Share on other sites

I never would have considered a macro lens for architecture, but I suppose it works all the same when the subject isn't close. Any idea why they would add shift capabilities to a lens like that rather than just a normal wide angle?

Regardless, it does look like a compelling option. How would it compare if I got something like the Laowa 12mm ZD and a Fotodiox Pro shift adapter (EF to X)? I don't suppose I could just use that adapter coupled with a reverse adapter to use my Fujifilm lenses, I imagine the extra space in front of the sensor would impact the image.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The Laowa 15mm f4 is kind of a bucket of everything lens. Laowa specializes in producing lenses with unusual close-focus properties (their regular macro lenses all go to 2:1 magnification for example). I have no idea why they added the shift feature, as it's APS-C only, but they did and it's useful. Macro focusing on a UWA allows for some truly unusual compositions and is an absolute ton of fun if you can live with a MFD that is less than 1cm from the front element.

You certainly could use the Laowa 12mm in EF mount and an EF mount shift adapter, that would actually be a better choice than the 15 as a replacement for the 17 TS-E (I mention the 15 solely because I own it and have experience with it, I bought it for my FF Nikon DSLR).

You can't stack adapters to do this with your Fuji lenses though. They don't have enough image circle to make a shift adapter worthwhile anyways, you really need a lens with FF coverage to make this viable (no EF-S lenses for example, only EF)

Edited by mawz
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...

I'm not sure it's worth it. I've tried some Nikon PC lenses and the results aren't acceptable besides for novelty value. And I'm not sure shifting adaptor would be much chop, I've got the Samyang 12mm about the same fov as the 17mm ts-e and the results aren't good enough for architecture (without an adaptor) I recently hired the Canon 17 ts-e and put it on an old 5d mk2 and the results are just immediately top. My conclusion, if you need the results such a lens can provide, then an older Canon is a better idea (i'm talking really about shifting for architecture but I suspect the same would go for product photography. Effect portraits etc are probably a different story) unless you go for a view camera option like the Cambo then is say the Canon is the only viable option 

Link to post
Share on other sites

@Lindsay Webb Yeah, I ended up going with a Laowa 12 mm EF lens plus a Fotodiox Pro shift adapter. It’s not the most ergonomic setup in the world, but it gets the job done with an 18 mm FF equivalence. In fact, it would have been silly to use a full frame TS lens on a crop sensor because the image circle would be far too big; the ratio of a TS lens to a FF sensor is the same as a FF lens to an APS-C sensor.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 11 months later...

Advertisement (gone after registration)

@robgillman hi! As I am currently looking into similar solutions (trying to avoid having to sell all fuji gear to go sony just to get Shift for architecture), how is the fotodiox+laowa12 working out for you now that it’s been a while ? 
Are you happy with the result ? Is for instance sharpness across the frame allright ? How about chromatic aberrations ?

thanks :) 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

  • Similar Content

    • By Gibby
      I'm shooting video with X-T4 on a gimbal, in continuous mode with face detect on.  If I try to change the focus point using the rear touch screen (pressing top right corner of screen until it gets to "AF", and then click on the desired focus point on the screen...it will refocus on that area, but only once.  As if it was switched to single focus mode.  The manual however, seems to indicate that the camera should remain in continuous focus mode and track that subject, which it doesn't.   I would like be able to click on a point using the rear screen and have the camera track in continuous focus.  Is this even possible?  Not clear in the manual.  tks.
    • By Gibby
      For stills, I'm using backbutton focus.  And I'm able to select the focus point and track it in continuous focus.  Works great.  But in video mode, I can't find a way to track an object - only a face using face detect.  The rear touch screen doesn't seem to work this way.  When I select a point, it behaves as single focus, even when the camera is set to continuous focus.  Also, I'm often using the camera on a gimbal and need to rely on the rear screen for setting the focus point.  To date, I've mainly had to use the X-T4 in manual mode for video which is disappointing.  Am I missing something?
    • By Théotim
      Hi all !
      After updating via app (1.23) my brand new x-t4 (work like a charm with 1.22 firmware) the EVF doesn't work at all now and if i try to switch to the EVF view every thing goes black and the camera get stuck like that forever... Even if i try to reboot it, the only option is to plug out/plug in the battery. Impossible to go back to the previous firmware (what a shame on a 2000€ camera). I'm very frustrated my camera is unusable... I update again the firmware with the classic SD option, the process finish the update without a problem but the problem persist cannot do anything with it now. If the camera go sleep... Stucked. If the eye sensor is activated for the EVF... Stucked. If i try to shutdown the camera... Stucked. 
      Thank you in advance.
      Best regard.
    • By R3D
      Hi All,

      Hope that some encountered that problem before and can help.
      I get my X-T4 a few weeks ago with FW 1.17 and it seemed to work correctly but just for the sake of having most up-to-date version I updated to 1.22). 
      After the update my fav view mode ([EYE SENSOR] + [LCD IMAGE DISP.]) is corrupted. It essentially keeps the LCD on whenever eye is away from EVF.
      Image preview is set 1.5 sec and is displayed correctly only on LCD screen. I set the LCD do info screen but it's not really how I'd like to have it working. 
      I was hoping that 1.23 will fix it but unfortunately no change after yesterday's release. 
      Thank you in advance! 
      R. 
       
    • By ccguy
      I'm trying to shoot with flash using a Godox 2.4GHz pair & strobe lights I've successfully used before; however, my only options in my flash menu settings are Manual & OFF. The button on the transmitter works with the receiver, but trying to use flash with the X-T4 has been unsuccessful. Are there any other settings that need to be enabled so it recognizes TTL/my hot shoe mount? 
  • Posts

×
×
  • Create New...